2014年11月29日星期六

Entry 21 edit the poem "When he was gone"


When He Was Gone       

I left the world behind, as your shadow crossed mine
The finger through my hair
locked in a black and white photo.
Once in a million years, a rose bled to death
but the blood no longer boiled under a violent moon
Memory was a bird that flies inside a bird.
She ate up stomach and extracted a broken soul
The sunset was a sinking ship on fire.
   The illusion of sunrise was reflected in the dying flame
Who is crying in the wind to catch the final straw?
Tears drill through the heart of a rock
without cutting any vessel or nerve
When he was gone, memory was just a overdue lie.



    What is working well (what requirements of good poetry are here?)
Obviously, this poem creates a lot of images like “a rose bled to death”, “The sunset was a sinking ship on fire.” It develops idea on how does protagonist feel when he was gone vividly. In addition, this topic express one’s hurt feeling can be accepted by most people. Therefore, it will much easier to arouse people’s emotion.
    What is not working (what requirements of "good poetry" are lacking? or not quite working?)
A good poem should be written in a concise and accurate language. If a poem can express its idea in minimum words, it will be a good poem. This poem has many words every sentence. It looks too wordy and redundant.
The imagination is in disorder. There is no relationship between one image into another image. What’s more, too much image will also distract audience’s attention and ignore the topic.
    What needs to be changed?
    Simplification and fluency
    Suggestions for how the poet might change.

    At first, it is better to make the sentence short, which will make poem much clearer. Also, there are too many images. I recommend only select one or two images to describe. It will make the topic stand out and engage audience’s emotion at ease. In addition, it is good to compress large idea and rethink an idea, which make this poem more impressive. Besides, adding some connections among those images will help to clarify the relationship between death and memory.

没有评论:

发表评论